Cover of 箱の中のあなた (Hako no Naka no Anata)

Intermediate · JLPT N3

箱の中のあなたHako no Naka no Anata — The Stranger in the Viewfinder

by Yamakawa Masao (山川方夫, 1930–1965)

  • JLPT N3
  • 3,337 characters
  • 3 parts
  • about 28 minutes
  • 2 easier versions

"The Stranger in the Viewfinder" (箱の中のあなた, literally "You Inside the Box") is a short psychological story by Yamakawa Masao. It is set in a provincial seaside tourist town at the start of summer. A breezy tourist from Tokyo asks a painfully shy woman in her thirties to take his picture on a hilltop at sunset. She cannot meet a man's eyes, but through the camera's viewfinder she can finally look at him freely. That small moment sets the story in motion. The narration stays close to her inner thoughts and is calm, restrained and quietly unsettling. The tension rests on what she feels rather than on what she says. For learners, the story is short (about 3,300 characters, measured at N3) and written in modern standard Japanese with no dialect. It also offers a clear contrast in speech styles: the man's easy desu/masu politeness against the woman's faltering feminine speech. The challenge is reading between the lines. Much depends on noticing how her perceptions shift, so the grammar of emphasis and limitation carries a lot of the meaning.

Contents

  1. A Photograph on the HilltopOn a hilltop at sunset, a smooth-talking tourist from the city asks a painfully shy woman in her thirties to take his photograph. She cannot look men in the face, but through the camera's viewfinder she can finally gaze at him as a small, harmless figure she can possess. As she presses the shutter, a sudden despairing resolve sweeps through her.
  2. A Walk to the Lonely CliffThe man asks to photograph the woman, and she suggests a park on the edge of town with a better view of the sea, so they go there. On the steep path he attacks her; she fights him off and kills him with a stone, then covers up the evidence and pushes his body off the cliff. The paper treats it as an accident, and the town soon begins to forget it.
  3. Her Collection of Smiling Dead MenThe woman collects the developed photographs and sets the picture of the man, bathed in red sunset light, in a frame on her dressing table. She tells it softly that she is sorry for killing him, but that only the dead can truly be hers. Then she remembers that today is the anniversary of another man's death, unlocks her bookcase, and happily studies a row of black-ribboned photographs of young men, all smiling in front of the same flame-shaped tree.

Easier versions

This story is also retold in simpler Japanese. Reading an easier version first makes the original much more approachable.

Before you read

  • Track the two speech styles. The man uses relaxed, friendly desu/masu. The woman uses hesitant feminine forms such as 〜ですわ, and in her final words to the photograph she shifts to soft, intimate endings (〜わ, 〜のよ, 〜ね). That shift in tone is part of the story's effect.
  • Learn the patterns that frame her way of seeing: 〜でしかない (is nothing but), 〜にちがいない (must surely be) and 〜さえ〜ば (if only). They often mark the moments when her view of the man changes, so read those sentences slowly.
  • Watch for 〜かける (to start to do something, or to be about to). The narration often catches actions half-begun, which suits the woman's hesitancy.
  • Expect a few older spellings. 染る appears where modern texts usually write 染まる, and 才 is used for 歳 in ages. Read them as you would the standard forms.
  • Before reading, learn some basic camera and setting vocabulary, such as 写真, シャッター, ファインダー and 断崖 (cliff). In part 3, notice how the recurring image of the flame-shaped tree and the red sunset light take on new meaning.

Words to know

The most useful words from the notes across the story.

WordMeaningJLPT
浴びたあびるto be bathed in (light), to be showered withdictionary form: 浴びるAlso used for showers: シャワーを浴びる.N5
一昨年いっさくねんthe year before lastIn everyday speech usually read おととし.N5
緊張きんちょうtension, nervousnessN3
慄えてふるえるto tremble, to shiverdictionary form: 慄えるUsually written 震える; 慄 adds a shade of dread or thrill.N3
裏切りうらぎるto betraydictionary form: 裏切るLiterally 'to cut from behind'.N3
焦点しょうてんfocus (of a lens)焦点が合う = to come into focus.N2
見下せるみおろすto look down over (a view), to overlookdictionary form: 見下ろすRead みくだす, the same kanji means 'to look down on, despise'.N2
夕刊ゆうかんevening edition of a newspaperThe morning edition is 朝刊 (ちょうかん).N2
臆病おくびょうtimidity, cowardiceAlso used as a na-adjective; 臆病さ in a later sentence is the noun form with 〜さ.N1
疑惑ぎわくsuspicion, doubtStronger and more formal than 疑い.N1
なれなれしくなれなれしいoverly familiar, too friendlydictionary form: なれなれしいSlightly negative: friendliness that oversteps distance with a stranger.N1
露骨ろこつopen, undisguised, blatantOften slightly negative: showing feelings too plainly.N1
現像げんぞうdeveloping (photographic film)現像する = to develop film; a word from the film-camera era.N1
染ったそまるto be dyed, to be tingeddictionary form: 染まるOlder spelling; today usually written 染まった.N1
ぎごちないぎごちないawkward, stiffAlso spelled ぎこちない, which is the more common form today.—

Plot summary

Show the full summary (contains spoilers)

A tourist from Tokyo asks a shy woman to photograph him on a hilltop. Through the viewfinder she sees him as small, harmless and somehow hers, and as she presses the shutter she feels a sudden, despairing resolve. He then offers to photograph her, and she suggests a park on the edge of town with a better view of the sea. On the steep path there, he attacks her. She fights back, kills him with a stone, covers up the evidence and pushes his body off the cliff locals call the Devil's Cliff. The paper reports an accident, and the town soon forgets. She frames his sunset-lit photo on her dressing table and tells it gently that only the dead can truly be hers. Then, remembering another man's death anniversary, she unlocks her bookcase. Inside is a row of black-ribboned photos of smiling young men, all taken before the same flame-shaped tree.

About the author

Yamakawa Masao (山川方夫) was a Tokyo-born writer and the son of the nihonga painter Yamakawa Shūhō. His own fiction was nominated several times for the Akutagawa Prize. He died at the age of thirty-four from injuries suffered in a traffic accident.

More stories by Yamakawa Masao →