
Part 3 of 4 · JLPT N2
桜桃 Ōtō, part 3: Losing Arguments, Starting a Quarrel
In this part
The narrator admits he never wins an argument and ends up drinking in frustration, then reveals that the story is really about a marital quarrel. When the wife speaks of a 'valley of tears', the husband takes it as a dig at him and silently recounts his own efforts for the family. He timidly suggests hiring help, but the wife coolly deflects it, and he falls silent again, thinking how badly they need someone, given the children and the daily visitors.
AI translation · independently checked
私は議論をして、勝ったためしが無い。I have never once argued with anyone and won.
必ず負けるのである。I always lose.
相手の確信の強さ、自己肯定のすさまじさに圧倒せられるのである。I am overwhelmed by the strength of the other person's conviction, by the sheer ferocity of their self-assurance.
そうして私は沈黙する。And so I fall silent.
しかし、だんだん考えてみると、相手の身勝手に気がつき、ただこっちばかりが悪いのではないのが確信せられて来るのだが、いちど言い負けたくせに、またしつこく戦闘開始するのも陰惨だし、それに私には言い争いは殴り合いと同じくらいにいつまでも不快な憎しみとして残るので、怒りにふるえながらも笑い、沈黙し、それから、いろいろさまざま考え、ついヤケ酒という事になるのである。Yet as I gradually think it over, I begin to notice the other person's selfishness and grow convinced that I am not the only one at fault. But having lost the argument once already, it would be dismal to stubbornly reopen hostilities. Besides, for me a quarrel lingers as an unpleasant hatred for just as long as a fistfight does. So, though I am trembling with anger, I laugh, I fall silent, I turn all sorts of things over in my mind, and before I know it, it comes down to drinking out of desperation.
はっきり言おう。Let me say it plainly.
くどくどと、あちこち持ってまわった書き方をしたが、実はこの小説、夫婦喧嘩の小説なのである。I have written in a tediously roundabout way, beating about the bush, but in fact this story is a story about a marital quarrel.
「涙の谷」"The valley of tears."
それが導火線であった。That was what lit the fuse.
この夫婦は既に述べたとおり、手荒なことはもちろん、口汚く罵り合った事さえないすこぶるおとなしい一組ではあるが、しかし、それだけまた一触即発の危険におののいているところもあった。As I have already said, this couple were an exceedingly mild pair. Far from ever raising a hand to each other, they had never even hurled foul abuse at each other. But for that very reason, there was also something in them that trembled at the danger of an explosion at the slightest touch.
両方が無言で、相手の悪さの証拠固めをしているような危険、一枚の札をちらと見ては伏せ、また一枚ちらと見ては伏せ、いつか、出し抜けに、さあ出来ましたと札をそろえて眼前にひろげられるような危険、それが夫婦を互いに遠慮深くさせていたと言って言えないところが無いでも無かった。It was the danger that each of them was silently gathering proof of the other's faults: glancing at one card and laying it face down, glancing at another and laying it face down, until one day, without warning, the other might say, "There, it's ready!", gather up the cards and spread them out before one's eyes. It would not be altogether wrong to say that it was this danger that made husband and wife so reserved with each other.
妻のほうはとにかく、夫のほうは、たたけばたたくほど、いくらでもホコリの出そうな男なのである。Leaving the wife aside, the husband was the sort of man who, the harder you beat him, the more dust he would give off.
「涙の谷」"The valley of tears."
そう言われて、夫は、ひがんだ。Hearing this, the husband took it as a dig at him.
しかし、言い争いは好まない。But he does not care for arguments.
沈黙した。He fell silent.
お前はおれに、いくぶんあてつける気持で、そう言ったのだろうが、しかし、泣いているのはお前だけでない。You said that partly to get at me, I suppose, but you're not the only one who's crying.
おれだって、お前に負けず、子供の事は考えている。I think about the children too, just as much as you do.
自分の家庭は大事だと思っている。I believe my family matters.
子供が夜中に、へんな咳一つしても、きっと眼がさめて、たまらない気持になる。If one of the children gives so much as a single odd cough in the night, I always wake up, and I can hardly bear it.
もう少し、ましな家に引越して、お前や子供たちをよろこばせてあげたくてならぬが、しかし、おれには、どうしてもそこまで手が廻らないのだ。I'm dying to move to a somewhat better house and make you and the children happy, but I just can't stretch that far, however hard I try.
これでもう、精一ぱいなのだ。As it is, I'm doing all I can.
おれだって、凶暴な魔物ではない。I'm not some savage monster either.
妻子を見殺しにして平然、というような「度胸」を持ってはいないのだ。I don't have the "nerve" to leave my wife and children to die and stay perfectly calm about it.
配給や登録の事だって、知らないのではない、知るひまが無いのだ。As for the rations and the registration, it isn't that I don't know about them. I don't have the time to know.
……父は、そう心の中で呟き、しかし、それを言い出す自信も無く、また、言い出して母から何か切りかえされたら、ぐうの音も出ないような気もして、…So the father muttered in his heart. But he lacked the confidence to come out with it, and he also felt that if he did, and the mother shot something back at him, he would not be able to make a peep. And so
「誰か、ひとを雇いなさい」"Hire someone."
と、ひとりごとみたいに、わずかに主張してみた次第なのだ。That was all he ventured to say, faintly, as if he were talking to himself.
母も、いったい、無口なほうである。The mother, too, is by nature a woman of few words.
しかし、言うことに、いつも、つめたい自信を持っていた。But she always had a cold confidence in what she said.
(この母に限らず、どこの女も、たいていそんなものであるが)(It is not only this mother. Most women, wherever you go, are much the same.)
「でも、なかなか、来てくれるひともありませんから」"But hardly anyone is willing to come, you see."
「捜せば、きっと見つかりますよ。来てくれるひとが無いんじゃ無い、いてくれるひとが無いんじゃないかな?」"If you look, you're sure to find someone. Maybe it's not that no one will come. Maybe it's that no one will stay?"
「私が、ひとを使うのが下手だとおっしゃるのですか?」"Are you saying that I am poor at managing help?"
「そんな、……」"Now, I didn't…"
父はまた黙した。The father fell silent again.
じつは、そう思っていたのだ。The truth was, that was exactly what he thought.
しかし、黙した。But he kept silent.
ああ、誰かひとり、雇ってくれたらいい。Oh, if only she would hire someone.
母が末の子を背負って、用足しに外に出かけると、父はあとの二人の子の世話を見なければならぬ。Whenever the mother goes out on errands with the youngest on her back, the father has to look after the other two children.
そうして、来客が毎日、きまって十人くらいずつある。And on top of that, every single day, about ten visitors call without fail.
Vocabulary
| Word | Meaning | JLPT |
|---|---|---|
| 圧倒あっとうする | to overwhelm, overpowerdictionary form: 圧倒するUsually used in the passive: 圧倒される, 'to be overwhelmed'. | — |
| 身勝手みがって | selfishness; selfishA な-adjective/noun; a stronger word than わがまま. | — |
| 陰惨いんさん | dismal, grim, gloomyA literary な-adjective. | — |
| ヤケ酒やけざけ | drinking out of desperation or frustrationdictionary form: やけ酒From やけ 'desperation, recklessness' plus 酒, with rendaku (さけ → ざけ). | — |
| 導火線どうかせん | fuse; the spark that sets something offLiterally 'a line that leads fire', and often used figuratively for a trigger. | — |
| 罵り合ったののしりあう | to hurl abuse at each otherdictionary form: 罵り合うVerb stem + 合う expresses a mutual action, as in 殴り合い, 'a fistfight'. | — |
| 一触即発いっしょくそくはつ | explosive; ready to blow up at the slightest touchA four-character idiom: 'one touch, instant explosion'. | — |
| 遠慮えんりょ | restraint, holding back out of consideration遠慮深い means 'very reserved, cautious with others'. | N4 |
| ひがんだひがむ | to take something as a slight, feel resentfuldictionary form: 僻むDescribes a jealous or warped way of seeing things; usually written in kana. | — |
| あてつけるあてつける | to make a pointed remark, have a dig at someonedictionary form: 当て付けるA comment aimed indirectly at someone in order to hurt them. | — |
| 見殺しみごろし | leaving someone to die without helping見殺しにする: 'to stand by and let someone die'. | — |
| 配給はいきゅう | rationing; rationsA key word of wartime and postwar Japan. | N1 |
| ぐうの音ぐうのね | a peep, the slightest sound of protestUsed in the set phrase ぐうの音も出ない, 'unable to say a word in reply'. | — |
| 雇いやとう | to hire, employdictionary form: 雇う | N3 |
Grammar
〜たためしが無い N1 has never (once) done
ためし means 'a precedent' or 'an instance'. After a past-tense verb, ためしがない emphatically says that something has never happened, often with a note of complaint or self-mockery.
私は議論をして、勝ったためしが無い。
I have never once argued with anyone and won.
〜せられる (literary passive of する-verbs) N1 is done (to me); is felt
せられる is an old-fashioned form of される. It gives the narration a stiff, bookish tone. 圧倒せられる simply means 圧倒される, 'to be overwhelmed'.
自己肯定のすさまじさに圧倒せられるのである。
I am overwhelmed by the sheer ferocity of their self-assurance.
〜くせに N3 even though; despite (critical)
くせに links two facts that clash, and it carries criticism or contempt. Here the narrator mocks himself for reopening a fight he has already lost.
いちど言い負けたくせに、またしつこく戦闘開始するのも陰惨だし
having lost the argument once already, it would be dismal to stubbornly reopen hostilities
〜ば〜ほど N3 the more ..., the more ...
The same verb is repeated, first in the ば form and then in the plain form + ほど, to show that one thing increases along with the other. This line plays on the saying 叩けば埃が出る, 'beat anyone and dust comes out', meaning that everyone has hidden faults.
たたけばたたくほど、いくらでもホコリの出そうな男なのである。
the harder you beat him, the more dust he would give off without end
〜たくてならぬ N2 to want desperately to; can't help wanting to
〜てならない (in old-fashioned form, ならぬ) after a feeling or desire means that the feeling is too strong to hold back. Here it is attached to the たい form, so the speaker longs to do something.
お前や子供たちをよろこばせてあげたくてならぬ
I'm dying to make you and the children happy
〜次第だ N1 that is how it came about; such is the situation
Placed after a plain-form clause, 次第だ explains the circumstances of an action: 'it is a matter of having done X; that is how it came about'. It sounds formal, and here it adds wry understatement about how little the father actually manages to say.
わずかに主張してみた次第なのだ。
That was all he ventured to say, faintly.