Part 3 of 7 · JLPT N2
春は馬車に乗って Haru wa Basha ni no Te, part 3: The Theory from Inside the Cage
In this part
The husband argues that everything he endures is really for his sick wife's sake. She accuses him of caring more for his work and deadlines than for her, and says she would rather die than be treated so coldly. He slips out to buy giblets for her, while her feverish, relentless reasoning wears away her own lungs.
AI translation · independently checked
「それはそうだ、俺はお前の云うように、俺のために何事も忍耐しているのにちがいない。"That's true enough. Just as you say, I must be putting up with everything for my own sake.
しかしだ、俺が俺のために忍耐していると云うことは、一体誰故にこんなことをしていなければ、ならないんだ。But here's the thing: if I'm putting up with it for my own sake, then who on earth am I supposed to be doing all this for?
俺はお前さえいなければ、こんな馬鹿な動物園の真似はしていたくないんだ。そこをしていると云うのは、誰のためだ。If it weren't for you, I'd have no wish to keep up this ridiculous zoo-animal act. So if I'm doing it anyway, who is it for?
お前以外の俺のためだとでも云うのか。馬鹿馬鹿しい」Are you going to tell me it's for some me that has nothing to do with you? Absurd."
こう云う夜になると、妻の熱は定って九度近くまで昇り出した。On nights like this, his wife's fever would invariably start climbing until it was close to thirty-nine degrees.
彼は一本の理論を鮮明にしたために、氷嚢の口を、開けたり閉めたり、夜通ししなければならなかった。Because he had made one line of reasoning perfectly clear, he had to spend the whole night opening and closing the mouth of the ice bag.
しかし、なお彼は自分の休息する理由の説明を明瞭にするために、この懲りるべき理由の整理を、殆ど日日し続けなければならなかった。And yet, to make his explanation of why he needed rest perfectly plain, he had to keep sorting through these reasons, which should have taught him his lesson, almost every single day.
彼は食うためと、病人を養うためとに別室で仕事をした。He worked in a separate room, both to feed himself and to support the invalid.
すると、彼女は、また檻の中の理論を持ち出して彼を攻めたてて来るのである。And then she would once again bring out her theory from inside the cage and come at him with it, attacking and attacking.
「あなたは、私の傍をどうしてそう離れたいんでしょう。今日はたった三度よりこの部屋へ来て下さらないんですもの。分っていてよ。あなたは、そう云う人なんですもの」Why do you want so badly to get away from my side? Today you've come into this room only three times. I know. That's just the kind of person you are.
「お前と云う奴は、俺がどうすればいいと云うんだ。俺は、お前の病気をよくするために、薬と食物とを買わなければならないんだ。誰がじっとしていて金をくれる奴があるものか。お前は俺に手品でも使えと云うんだね」"You really are something. What do you expect me to do? I have to buy medicine and food to make you better. Who's going to hand me money while I just sit here? Are you telling me to pull it out of a hat by magic?"
「だって、仕事なら、ここでも出来るでしょう」と妻は云った。"But you could do your work in here, couldn't you?" said his wife.
「いや、ここでは出来ない。俺はほんの少しでも、お前のことを忘れているときでなければ出来ないんだ」"No, I can't do it here. I can only work when I've forgotten about you, even for a little while."
「そりゃそうですわ。あなたは、二十四時間仕事のことより何も考えない人なんですもの、あたしなんか、どうだっていいんですわ」Well, of course. You're the kind of person who thinks of nothing but work, twenty-four hours a day, so someone like me doesn't matter at all.
「お前の敵は俺の仕事だ。しかし、お前の敵は、実は絶えずお前を助けているんだよ」"Your enemy is my work. But that enemy of yours is actually helping you all the time, you know."
「あたし、淋しいの」"I'm lonely."
「いずれ、誰だって淋しいにちがいない」"One way or another, everyone's bound to be lonely."
「あなたはいいわ。仕事があるんですもの。あたしは何もないんだわ」"It's all right for you. You've got your work. I've got nothing at all."
「捜せばいいじゃないか」"Then why not look for something?"
「あたしは、あなた以外に捜せないんです。あたしは、じっと天井を見て寝てばかりいるんです」"I can't look for anything but you. All I ever do is lie here staring at the ceiling."
「もう、そこらでやめてくれ。どちらも淋しいとしておこう。俺には締切りがある。今日書き上げないと、向うがどんなに困るかしれないんだ」"That's enough, stop there. Let's just say we're both lonely. I have a deadline. If I don't finish writing this today, there's no telling how much trouble it'll cause them."
「どうせ、あなたはそうよ。あたしより、締切りの方が大切なんですから」"Well, that's how you are anyway. Your deadline matters more than I do."
「いや、締切りと云うことは、相手のいかなる事情をも退けると云う張り札なんだ。俺はこの張り札を見て引き受けて了った以上、自分の事情なんか考えてはいられない」"No. A deadline is a posted notice that brushes aside whatever circumstances the other side may have. Once I've read that notice and taken the job on, I can't go thinking about my own circumstances."
「そうよ、あなたはそれほど理智的なのよ。いつでもそうなの、あたし、そう云う理智的な人は、大嫌い」"Yes, that's how rational you are. You're always like that. And I hate rational people like that."
「お前は俺の家の者である以上、他から来た張り札に対しては、俺と同じ責任を持たなければならないんだ」"As long as you're part of my household, you have to bear the same responsibility I do toward a notice that comes from outside."
「そんなもの、引き受けなければいいじゃありませんか」"Then why not just refuse to take such things on?"
「しかし、俺とお前の生活はどうなるんだ」"But then what becomes of our life, yours and mine?"
「あたし、あなたがそんなに冷淡になる位なら、死んだ方がいいの」"If you're going to be as cold as that, I'd rather die."
すると、彼は黙って庭へ飛び降りて深呼吸をした。At that, he said nothing, jumped down into the garden and took a deep breath.
それから、彼はまた風呂敷を持って、その日の臓物を買いにこっそりと町の中へ出かけていった。Then he took up the cloth wrapper once more and slipped quietly out into town to buy the day's giblets.
しかし、この彼女の「檻の中の理論」は、その檻に繋がれて廻っている彼の理論を、絶えず全身的な興奮をもって、殆ど間髪の隙間をさえも洩らさずに追っ駈けて来るのである。But this "theory from inside the cage" of hers kept chasing after his own theory, which circled round and round tethered to that very cage, always with a fevered excitement that seized her whole body, scarcely leaving a hair's breadth of a gap.
このため彼女は、彼女の檻の中で製造する病的な理論の鋭利さのために、自身の肺の組織を日日加速度的に破壊していった。And so, through the very sharpness of the sickly theories she manufactured inside her cage, she went on destroying the tissue of her own lungs day by day, faster and faster.
Vocabulary
| Word | Meaning | JLPT |
|---|---|---|
| 忍耐にんたい | endurance, patience; putting up with hardshipUsed here with する: 忍耐する = to endure. More formal than 我慢する. | — |
| 氷嚢ひょうのう | ice bag (for cooling a fever)嚢 means 'bag, sack'; a rare kanji. | — |
| 夜通しよどおし | all night long通し = 'right through'; compare 一晩中. | — |
| 懲りるこりる | to learn one's lesson (from a bad experience)懲りるべき理由 = reasons that ought to have taught him better. | N1 |
| 養うやしなう | to support, provide for (a dependent) | N1 |
| 檻おり | cage (for an animal)A key image: the sick wife reasons from inside a 'cage', the husband paces tethered to it. | N1 |
| 攻めたててせめたてる | to attack relentlessly, press harddictionary form: 攻め立てる〜立てる adds the sense of doing something vigorously and repeatedly. | — |
| 手品てじな | magic trick, sleight of hand | N3 |
| 締切りしめきり | deadlinedictionary form: 締め切り | N2 |
| 張り札はりふだ | posted notice, placardOld-fashioned; the modern word is 貼り紙. | — |
| 理智的りちてき | rational, intellectual, coolly reasoningNow usually written 理知的. | — |
| 冷淡れいたん | cold, indifferent, unfeelingA な-adjective: 冷淡になる = to become cold toward someone. | N1 |
| 臓物ぞうもつ | giblets, offal (internal organs used as food) | — |
| 間髪かんはつ | a hair's breadthBest known from the idiom 間髪を入れず 'without a moment's delay'. | — |
Grammar
〜にちがいない N3 must be, surely
Expresses the speaker's strong conviction that something is true. The husband sarcastically concedes the wife's accusation as if it were certain.
俺のために何事も忍耐しているのにちがいない
I must be putting up with everything for my own sake
〜さえ〜ば N3 if only, as long as (just this one thing)
さえ marks a single condition that alone decides the result. Here it is negative: 'if only you weren't there', implying she is the sole reason for his effort.
俺はお前さえいなければ、こんな馬鹿な動物園の真似はしていたくないんだ。
If it weren't for you, I'd have no wish to keep up this ridiculous zoo-animal act.
〜んですもの N3 because, after all (feminine, complaining)
もの at the end of a sentence gives a reason in a sulky or self-justifying way, typical of soft feminine speech. The wife uses it repeatedly to justify her complaints.
あなたは、そう云う人なんですもの
That's just the kind of person you are, after all
〜以上(は) N2 since, now that, as long as
After a verb or noun + である, 以上(は) states a fact that brings an obligation with it ('since/now that ~, then naturally ~'). Once he has accepted the work, he cannot consider his own situation.
俺はこの張り札を見て引き受けて了った以上、自分の事情なんか考えてはいられない
Once I've read that notice and taken the job on, I can't go thinking about my own circumstances
どんなに〜かしれない N2 there's no knowing how (much)…
An intensifying expression meaning the degree is too great to measure; modern Japanese often uses 〜かわからない. Here it stresses how badly the publisher would be affected.
今日書き上げないと、向うがどんなに困るかしれないんだ
If I don't finish writing this today, there's no telling how much trouble it'll cause them
〜くらいなら〜方がいい N2 rather than…, I'd prefer…
くらいなら presents something as so undesirable that even the alternative is better. The wife says death would be preferable to his coldness.
あたし、あなたがそんなに冷淡になる位なら、死んだ方がいいの
If you're going to be as cold as that, I'd rather die