Cover of 少女病 (Shōjobyō)

Part 5 of 8 · JLPT N2

少女病(三(つづき)) Shōjobyō, part 5: The Friends Diagnose the Master

by Tayama Katai · 1,097 characters · from The Girl Malady

In this part

Sugita's friends gossip about his habit of merely admiring young girls and argue over its cause. One claims it is simply his nature, but another insists, citing a doctor, that it is a physiological disorder brought on by excessive solitary indulgence in his youth. He ends with a long, confident speech on the supremacy of instinct.

AI translation · independently checked

ある時とき、友人ゆうじん間かんでその噂うわさがあった時とき、一人ひとりは言いった。Once, when this rumour was going round among his friends, one of them said:

「どうも不思議ふしぎだ。一種いっしゅの病気びょうきかもしれんよ。先生せんせいのはただ、あくがれるというばかりなのだからね。美うつくしいと思おもう、ただそれだけなのだ。我々われわれなら、そういう時ときには、すぐ本能ほんのうの力ちからが首くびを出だしてきて、ただ、あくがれるくらいではどうしても満足まんぞくができんがね」"It's a strange business. It may be a kind of illness, you know. With the Master it's only a matter of longing, after all. He thinks a girl beautiful, and that is all there is to it. With fellows like us, at such a moment instinct pokes its head up at once, and mere longing would never satisfy us."

「そうとも、生理的せいりてきに、どこか陥落ろすとしているんじゃないかしらん」"Quite so. I wonder whether something hasn't been 'lost' in him, physiologically speaking."

と言いったものがある。So said another.

「生理的せいりてきと言いうよりも性質せいしつじゃないかしらん」"I wonder whether it isn't his nature rather than his physiology."

「いや、僕ぼくはそうは思おもわん。先生せんせい、若わかい時分じぶん、あまりにほしいままなことをしたんじゃないかと思おもうね」"No, I don't think so. I rather suspect the Master indulged himself far too freely when he was young."

「ほしいままとは?」"Indulged himself how?"

「言いわずともわかるじゃないか……。ひとりであまり身みを傷きずつけたのさ。その習慣しゅうかんが長ながく続つづくと、生理的せいりてきに、ある方面ほうめんがロストしてしまって、肉にくと霊れいとがしっくり合あわんそうだ」"Surely you understand without my saying it…. He abused himself too much, alone. They say that if the habit goes on for a long time, something in a certain quarter is lost physiologically, and the flesh and the spirit no longer fit together properly."

「ばかな……」"Nonsense…"

と笑わらったものがある。So laughed another.

「だッて、子供こどもができるじゃないか」"But he has children, hasn't he?"

と誰だれかが言いった。Someone said.

「それは子供こどもはできるさ……」と前まえの男おとこは受うけて、「僕ぼくは医者いしゃに聞きいたんだが、その結果けっかはいろいろあるそうだ。はげしいのは、生殖せいしょくの途みちが絶たたれてしまうそうだが、中なかには先生せんせいのようになるのもあるということだ。よく例れいがあるって……僕ぼくにいろいろ教おしえてくれたよ。僕ぼくはきっとそうだと思おもう。僕ぼくの鑑定かんていは誤あやまらんさ」"Oh, he can have children, certainly…" the first man replied. "I asked a doctor about it, and he says the results vary. In severe cases the path of reproduction is cut off altogether, but some, it seems, end up like the Master. There are plenty of such cases, he said… he told me all sorts of things. I'm sure that's what it is. My judgement doesn't err."

「僕ぼくは性質せいしつだと思おもうがね」"I still think it's his nature."

「いや、病気びょうきですよ、少すこし海岸かいがんにでも行いっていい空気くうきでも吸すって、節慾せつよくしなければいかんと思おもう」"No, it's an illness. I think he ought to go off to the seaside or somewhere, breathe some good air, and practise restraint."

「だって、あまりおかしい、それも十八じゅうはち、九きゅうとか二十二にじゅうに、三さんとかなら、そういうこともあるかもしれんが、細君さいくんがあって、子供こどもが二人ふたりまであって、そして年としは三十八さんじゅうはちにもなろうというんじゃないか。君きみの言いうことは生理学せいりがく万能ばんのうで、どうも断定だんていすぎるよ」"But it's too absurd. If he were eighteen or nineteen, or twenty-two or twenty-three, such a thing might happen, but here is a man with a wife, with two children even, and he'll soon be thirty-eight. You make physiology the answer to everything; you're far too dogmatic."

「いや、それは説明せつめいができる。十八じゅうはち、九きゅうでなければそういうことはあるまいと言ゆうけれど、それはいくらもある。"No, it can be explained. You say such things wouldn't happen unless a man were eighteen or nineteen, but there are any number of cases.

先生せんせい、きっと今いまでもやっているに相違そういない。若わかい時とき、ああいうふうで、むやみに恋愛れんあい神聖しんせい論ろん者しゃを気きどって、口くちではきれいなことを言いっていても、本能ほんのうが承知しょうちしないから、ついみずから傷きずつけて快かいを取とるというようなことになる。I'll wager the Master is still at it even now. When he was young he was like that, posing recklessly as an apostle of the sanctity of love, and though he spoke fine words, his instinct would not consent, and so before he knew it he would end up taking his pleasure by abusing himself.

そしてそれが習慣しゅうかんになると、病的びょうてきになって、本能ほんのうの充分じゅうぶんの働はたらきをすることができなくなる。And once that becomes a habit, it turns morbid, and the instinct can no longer do its proper work.

先生せんせいのはきっとそれだ。つまり、前まえにも言いったが、肉にくと霊れいとがしっくり調和ちょうわすることができんのだよ。That's surely the Master's case. In short, as I said before, his flesh and his spirit cannot be brought into proper harmony.

それにしてもおもしろいじゃないか、健全けんぜんをもってみずからも任にんじ、人ひとも許ゆるしていたものが、今いまでは不健全ふけんぜんも不健全ふけんぜん、デカダンの標本ひょうほんになったのは、これというのも本能ほんのうをないがしろにしたからだ。All the same, isn't it amusing? A man who counted himself, and was counted by others, as the very picture of health has now become unhealthy beyond all measure, a specimen of decadence, and it all comes from having slighted his instinct.

君きみたちは僕ぼくが本能ほんのう万能ばんのう説せつを抱いだいているのをいつも攻撃こうげきするけれど、実際じっさい、人間にんげんは本能ほんのうがたいせつだよ。You fellows are always attacking me for holding that instinct is everything, but in truth, instinct is what matters in a human being.

本能ほんのうに従したがわん奴やつは生存せいぞんしておられんさ」と滔々とうとうとして弁べんじた。A fellow who won't obey his instinct can't survive," he declaimed in a ready flood of words.

Vocabulary

WordMeaningJLPT
噂うわさrumour, gossip噂がある: there is talk (about someone).N3
あくがれるあくがれるto long for, to yearn afterOlder form of modern あこがれる (憧れる).—
本能ほんのうinstinctThe key word of the speaker's theory; 本能万能説 means 'the theory that instinct is all-powerful'.N1
陥落かんらくloss, collapse (here glossed as 'lost')Normally かんらく 'fall, surrender'; the author gives it the English reading ロスト.—
ほしいままほしいままself-indulgent, unrestrainedWritten 恣 or 擅 in kanji; ほしいままにする means 'to do as one pleases'.—
傷つけたきずつけるto injure, to harmdictionary form: 傷つける身を傷つける / みずから傷つける is used here as a euphemism for self-abuse.—
霊れいspirit, soul肉と霊 'flesh and spirit' was a favourite Meiji-era pairing.—
細君さいくんwife (one's own or another's)Old-fashioned, casual word used among men.—
断定だんていfirm conclusion; dogmatic judgement断定すぎる: too categorical.N2
気どってきどるto pose as, to put on airsdictionary form: 気どるXを気どる: to play the part of X.—
ないがしろないがしろneglect, disregardUsually ないがしろにする 'to slight, to make light of'.—
標本ひょうほんspecimen, typical exampleLiterally a scientific specimen; used ironically here.N2
滔々とうとうfluently, in a torrent of wordsOriginally describes a great river flowing; 滔々と弁じる means 'to hold forth'.—

Grammar

〜ん (negative) N3 casual negative = 〜ない

Male speakers of the period, and some dialects, shorten 〜ない to 〜ん. できん = できない, 思わん = 思わない, 合わん = 合わない.

一種の病気かもしれんよ。

It may be a kind of illness, you know.

〜ずとも N1 even without doing ~

ず is the classical negative, and とも adds 'even if'. 言わずとも therefore means 'even without saying it', the same as modern 言わなくても.

言わずともわかるじゃないか……。

Surely you understand without my saying it….

〜まい N2 probably not ~; surely not ~

まい expresses negative conjecture. あるまい is equivalent to ないだろう.

十八、九でなければそういうことはあるまいと言うけれど

You say such things wouldn't happen unless a man were eighteen or nineteen

〜に相違ない N2 must be ~; without doubt ~

This is a formal, written equivalent of 〜に違いない. It shows that the speaker is strongly convinced.

先生、きっと今でもやっているに相違ない。

I'll wager the Master is still at it even now.

〜をもって任じる N1 to regard oneself as ~

Xをもって(自ら)任じる means to consider oneself X. Here the speaker sets it beside 人も許す, meaning 'others also acknowledged him as X'.

健全をもってみずからも任じ、人も許していたもの

a man who counted himself, and was counted by others, as the very picture of health

〜と言ったものがある N1 someone said ~

This is a literary way of introducing an unnamed speaker. Literally it means 'there was one who said'. The same pattern appears as と笑ったものがある.

と言ったものがある。

So said another.