
Part 5 of 9 · JLPT N2
恋愛曲線 Ren'aikyokusen, part 5: Measuring Emotion in a Severed Heart
In this part
The narrator explains his method. He first recorded how known drugs and poisons change the curve of an excised heart, as a control. His real aim was to find out how emotions change the blood and so the heart. Rabbits proved too expressionless to use, and dogs grew furious whenever blood was drawn, so only the curves for rage and fear came close to what he wanted.
AI translation · independently checked
さて、僕は先ず、僕の研究の準備として、切り出した心臓について、諸種の薬物の作用を研究したのだ。Now, as a preparation for my research, I first studied the action of various drugs upon the excised heart.
即ち、最初にロック氏液を心臓に通じて、常態の曲線を写真に撮り、然る後試験しようと思う薬品をロック氏液に混じて通じ、そのときに起る心臓の変化を曲線として撮影するのである。That is to say, I first passed Locke's solution through the heart and photographed its normal curve; thereafter I mixed the drug I wished to test into the Locke's solution, passed that through, and recorded the changes then occurring in the heart as a curve.
肉眼で見て居るだけでは、あまり変化がないようであるけれども、曲線を比較して見ると、明かな変化を認め、それによって、その薬物が心臓に如何なる風に作用したかを知ることが出来るのだ。To the naked eye there appears to be little change, but when the curves are compared a distinct change can be seen, and from it one can tell in what manner the drug has acted upon the heart.
ジギタリス剤、アトロピン、ムスカリン等の猛毒からアドレナリン、カンフル、カフェイン等の薬剤に至るまで心臓に作用する毒物薬物の殆どすべてにわたって、僕は一々の曲線を作り上げたのだ。From deadly poisons such as the digitalis preparations, atropine and muscarine, down to medicines such as adrenaline, camphor and caffeine, I produced a curve for each one of very nearly all the poisons and drugs that act upon the heart.
然し、これだけのことは、別に新らしい研究ではなく、すでに多くの人によって試みられた所であって、要するに僕の本研究の対照試験に過ぎなかった。This much, however, was nothing particularly new; it had already been attempted by many others, and in short it was no more than a control experiment for my research proper.
然らば僕の本研究は何物であるかというに、一口にいえば、各種の情緒と心臓機能との関係だ。What, then, was my research proper? In a word, it was the relationship between the various emotions and the function of the heart.
即ち俗にいう喜怒哀楽の諸情が発現したとき、心臓はその電気発生の状態に如何なる変化を来すかということだ。That is to say: when the feelings commonly called joy, anger, sorrow and pleasure arise, what change does the heart undergo in the state of its electrical activity?
誰しも経験するとおり、驚いた時や怒ったときには、心臓の鼓動が変化する。As everyone knows from experience, when we are startled or angry, the beating of the heart changes.
僕はそれを切り出した心臓について、所謂客観的に観察したいと思ったのだ。I wished to observe this, in a so-called objective manner, using the excised heart.
恐怖の際に血中にアドレナリンが増加するという事実は既に他の学者の認めたところであるから、恐怖の際の血液を、切り出した心臓に通じたならば、アドレナリンを通じたときと、同じ変化が曲線の上にあらわれるべき筈だ。It is a fact already established by other scientists that adrenaline increases in the blood at times of fear; therefore, if blood drawn during fear were passed through an excised heart, the same change ought to appear on the curve as when adrenaline is passed through it.
この事実から類推するときは、恐怖以外の他の諸情緒の際にも、血液に何等かの変化があるべき筈で、従って、動物に喜怒哀楽の諸情を起さしめ、その時の血液を、切り出した心臓に通じて、電気心働計によって曲線を撮ったならば、各種の情緒発現の際、血液中にどういう性質の物質があらわれるかを推定することが出来る訳である。Reasoning by analogy from this fact, there ought to be some change in the blood during emotions other than fear as well; consequently, if one aroused in an animal the feelings of joy, anger, sorrow and pleasure, passed the blood drawn at that moment through an excised heart, and took curves with the electrocardiograph, one would be able to infer what kind of substances appear in the blood when each of the various emotions arises.
然し、このような研究には、言う迄もなく幾多の困難が伴うものだ。Needless to say, however, research of this kind is attended by a great many difficulties.
理想的に言えば、心臓を切り出した同じ動物を怒らせたり、苦しませたりして、その血液を通じなくてはならぬが、それは出来ない相談だ。Ideally, one ought to anger or torment the very animal from which the heart was excised and pass its own blood through, but that is out of the question.
で、致し方がないから、甲の兎の心臓、乙の兎の種々の情緒発現時に於ける血液を採って、それを通じて研究することにした。And so, there being no other way, I decided to take the heart of one rabbit, and blood drawn from a second rabbit while it displayed various emotions, and to carry out the research by passing the one through the other.
次になお一層困難なことは、兎を怒らせたり、悲しませたりすることだ。Next, and more difficult still, was the task of making a rabbit angry or sad.
兎は元来無表情に見える動物であるから、その顔付から、喜怒哀楽の情を認めることは出来ず、従って、怒らせたつもりでも兎は案外怒っても居らず、又楽しませたつもりでも、兎は案外楽しんで居らぬかも知れぬのには、はたと当惑せざるを得なかった。The rabbit is by nature an animal that appears expressionless, so one cannot read joy, anger, sorrow or pleasure from its face; consequently, a rabbit I believed I had angered might in fact not be angry at all, and a rabbit I believed I had pleased might in fact feel no pleasure whatever, and at this I could not help being brought up short in perplexity.
そこで、僕は兎の実験を中止して、犬について行って見ることにした。I therefore abandoned the experiments on rabbits and decided to try them with dogs.
即ち甲の犬の心臓を切り出して、然る後乙の犬を怒らせ又は楽しませて、その血液を採って通過せしめたのだ。That is, I excised the heart of one dog, then angered or pleased a second dog, drew its blood, and passed that through.
それによって曲線を作ることは出来たけれど、やっぱり、理想的ではないのだ。By this means I was able to obtain curves, but still the method was not ideal.
というのは、折角犬を楽しませてもいざ血を採るとなると大いに怒るので、結局怒りの曲線に近いものが出来、それかといって犬を麻酔せしむれば、無情緒の曲線しか取れない訳で、たゞ憤怒の際、又は恐怖の際の曲線だけが比較的理想に近いものとなった訳である。For however much trouble I took to please a dog, the moment it came to drawing its blood it grew thoroughly enraged, so that what I obtained in the end was something close to the curve of anger; yet if, on the other hand, I anaesthetised the dog, I could obtain only a curve without emotion; and so only the curves for rage and for fear came comparatively close to the ideal.
Vocabulary
| Word | Meaning | JLPT |
|---|---|---|
| 切り出したきりだす | to cut out; to excise (an organ)dictionary form: 切り出すIn everyday use it more often means 'to bring up (a topic)'; here it is literal. | — |
| 作用さよう | action, effect (of a drug on the body)作用する = to act on; 副作用 = side effect. | N1 |
| 曲線きょくせん | curve (on a graph or recording)Key word of the story's title; opposite of 直線 (straight line). | N2 |
| 猛毒もうどく | deadly poison猛 = fierce, as in 猛烈. | — |
| 対照試験たいしょうしけん | control experimentDo not confuse 対照 (contrast, control) with 対象 (object, target). | — |
| 情緒じょうちょ | emotion, feelingAlso read じょうしょ. In modern Japanese often 'atmosphere, charm' (情緒がある). | N1 |
| 喜怒きどあいらく | joy, anger, sorrow and pleasure; the full range of human emotionsdictionary form: 喜怒哀楽A four-character idiom made of four emotions. | — |
| 類推るいすい | reasoning by analogy類 = similar kind, 推 = infer. | N1 |
| 推定すいてい | inference, estimationCommon in news: 推定年齢 = estimated age. | N2 |
| 甲こう | the first (of two); A甲 and 乙 (おつ) are used like 'A' and 'B' to label things in legal or scientific writing. | N1 |
| 当惑とうわく | perplexity, bewildermentはたと adds the sense of being suddenly brought to a halt. | — |
| 折角せっかく | with much trouble; despite the effortImplies the effort is wasted or spoiled, as here. | N2 |
| 麻酔ますい | anaesthesia; to anaesthetise麻 = numb, 酔 = intoxicated. | N1 |
| 憤怒ふんぬ | rage, furyA literary, stronger word than 怒り. Also read ふんど. | — |
Grammar
〜に過ぎない N3 is nothing more than; merely
Placed after a noun, it plays something down as only that and no more. Here the narrator shows the drug experiments were only a preliminary step.
要するに僕の本研究の対照試験に過ぎなかった
in short, it was no more than a control experiment for my research proper
〜べき筈だ N2 ought to; should by rights
べき (what is proper or expected) and 筈 (logical expectation) are combined for emphasis. The narrator uses it to state what his theory predicts should happen.
同じ変化が曲線の上にあらわれるべき筈だ
the same change ought to appear on the curve
〜しめる / 〜せしめる N1 to make or let (someone) do; literary causative
This is the classical causative, equivalent to modern 〜させる. 起さしめ means 起こさせ, 通過せしめた means 通過させた, and 麻酔せしむれば is a conditional form meaning 麻酔させれば.
動物に喜怒哀楽の諸情を起さしめ
if one aroused in an animal the feelings of joy, anger, sorrow and pleasure
〜たつもりでも N3 even though one believes one has done
Past tense plus つもり describes what one thinks one has done, which may not match reality. With でも it stresses the gap between belief and fact.
怒らせたつもりでも兎は案外怒っても居らず
a rabbit I believed I had angered might in fact not be angry at all
〜ざるを得ない N2 cannot help but; have no choice but to
ざる is the classical negative of the verb (せざる from する), and を得ない means 'cannot obtain'. The double negative gives 'could not avoid doing'.
はたと当惑せざるを得なかった
I could not help being brought up short in perplexity
いざ〜となると N2 when it actually comes to (doing)
This marks the moment when something stops being theoretical and has to be done, often with an unwelcome result. Here the dog turns angry the moment its blood is drawn.
いざ血を採るとなると大いに怒るので
the moment it came to drawing its blood it grew thoroughly enraged